The great pie controversy that has consumed Corduroy Falls for the past week came to a satisfying conclusion Thursday evening when contest judges declared an unprecedented tie between Ernestine Polk and Mavis Lucille Greene.
The resolution came after Loretta Faye Bingham discovered a crucial piece of evidence while sorting mail at the post office. A recipe card addressed to Ernestine had been accidentally delivered to Mavis's house on Sycamore Street the morning of the contest, while Mavis's own recipe went to the diner. Both women, in their haste to prepare entries, grabbed whichever crust recipe lay nearest at hand.
"Well, I'll be," Mavis laughed when the discovery came to light. "All this fuss, and we'd been using each other's secrets the whole blessed time."
The judges—Principal Horace Dunlap, Dorothy Lee Campbell, and Dr. Harold Whitfield—reconvened Thursday to taste both pies again with this new information in mind. After considerable deliberation at Ernestine's Diner, they announced that both desserts demonstrated equal merit, though achieved through different techniques.
Odell Rayburn, who had been taking informal bets at his barber shop on Oak Street, cheerfully refunded all wagers. "Can't say I've ever seen anything quite like it," he noted while sweeping up. "Probably for the best, though. Town was getting a mite too worked up over pastry."
The controversy had divided opinion throughout Corduroy Falls, with passionate advocates on both sides debating crust thickness, filling consistency, and lattice work at nearly every gathering place in town.
Both winners will receive blue ribbons at next month's Grange Hall ceremony. Ernestine has already offered to teach Mavis her meringue technique, while Mavis promised to share her secrets for preventing soggy bottoms.
"Reckon we both learned something," Ernestine observed while serving coffee to the relieved judges. The two women have agreed to enter a joint pie next year, combining their considerable talents into what promises to be a formidable dessert indeed.