The Great Pie Contest Scandal reached its dramatic conclusion Tuesday evening when a hastily assembled panel of judges awarded first prize to Curtis Leroy Hayes for his strawberry-rhubarb creation, ending nearly a week of heated debate that had divided the town along dessert lines.
The controversy began at last Saturday's Spring Social when initial judge Mavis Lucille Greene declared the contest "too close to call" after sampling entries from Hayes and diner owner Ernestine Polk. What followed became the talk of every establishment on Main Street, with partisans of both pies engaging in spirited debates at Odell's Barber Shop and Campbell's Grocery.
"I've tasted pies from here to Memphis, and I stand by my decision," Greene announced at Tuesday's emergency judging session held in the Methodist Church fellowship hall. The new panel, which included Principal Horace Dunlap and pharmacist Franklin Price, sampled fresh pies baked by both contestants under supervised conditions.
Hayes, who works at the Corduroy Five-and-Dime, accepted his blue ribbon with characteristic charm. "I learned this recipe from my grandmother," he explained, "and I'm just honored folks think it's worth all this fuss." His wife, librarian Ruby Nell Simmons, beamed from the audience.
Polk, however, remained unconvinced. "That crust was store-bought, I'd stake my reputation on it," she muttered while serving coffee to spectators. Despite her objections, she graciously shook Hayes's hand after the announcement.
The judging panel emphasized that both pies demonstrated exceptional quality. Price noted that the decision came down to "a matter of personal preference rather than any deficiency in either entry."
While the pie controversy dominated conversation, some residents expressed relief at the resolution. "We've got bigger fish to fry," observed Luther Washington, who attended the judging before returning to his spring planting preparations. "Though I wouldn't mind a slice of either pie while we figure out what to do about that highway bypass."
The Spring Social organizing committee has announced that next year's contest will feature clearly defined judging criteria and a panel of three judges from the outset.